in Search
1/3,038 members online
Immortality

reason

A Thought For the Day on Aging

(Crossposted from Fight Aging!)

A thought for the day, from a recent FuturePundit post:

Brain aging is gradual brain damage. Some people think aging is wonderful and natural. That's tantamount to saying that brain damage is wonderful and natural.

While progressive brain degeneration with age is not wonderful, it most certainly is natural - just like anthrax, parasites, suffering, living in caves and having a life expectancy of somewhere south of 30. Our present human condition is, thankfully, far removed from those past natural states. The reason it is far removed from that is, of course, because many, many people have labored to make it so through the advancement of medical science and other enabling technologies. The present human condition deserves its label by virtue of having been manufactured by humans, not because it is something that happens to humans.

We're not done with that manufacturing process, however, not by a long chalk. Anything and everything we don't like about the human condition is up for engineering in the years ahead. The purpose of that engineering is to provide choice: the choice not to live in caves, not to host parasites, not to suffer and die.

People who think aging is wonderful have their heads stuck in the sand; given the choice, almost all would opt to avoid suffering, degeneration and mandatory death by aging on a schedule other than their own. It's a damn shame we don't have that choice today, and so we see people strive to convince themselves that the ugly state of affairs they're stuck with is the best of things. In doing so, however, they shut off discussion about engineering a better future, cutting off their lives to save a little existential angst in the present.

Now that we're entering the era of rapidly advancing biotechnology, and there is a clear path ahead to producing medical technologies capable of rejuvenation of the old, the biggest obstacle to progress is a world of people convinced that aging and dying is the only option - indeed, that it is wonderful and noble. The more people we can win away from that cliff, the faster progress in the science of rejuvenation will advance. At the largest scales and over decades, widespread public support and understanding is what drives research onward.

Published Friday, January 18, 2008 6:06 PM by reason

Comment Notification

Join or sign in to track comments

Comments

 

VINCENT WAY wrote on February 2, 2008 11:42 PM

The only proven remedy for the elimination of old age is a young death.  If there were any other way, certainly the very rich would not be dying.  

It's bad enough to be deteriorating like a spawing salmon - but to realize just before you die that you have given your life savings to a low life snake oil merchant has to be the ultimate bad joke.

The sickness called old age may be cured some day - however, that day is a long way off.

 

Dmitri wrote on February 4, 2008 1:47 PM

Brain damage is not aging, nor is aging brain damage. This is an oversimplification of the human condition. Those who say that aging is wonderful do not imply that one of its consequent symptoms, namely damage to the brain and the body as a whole, is also wonderful. The wonder comes from the experience of having lived the life one has lived.

I find it is interesting that you say "manufacturing process" in referring to advances in medical and other life sciences. For this seems to imply that we humans are production units coming off an assembly line. Does that not strike you as question begging with regards to transhumanism? I would also question what is it precisely that you find troubling about aging and death. Is it the actual process, or is it the symptoms? Is it simply death, or death in agony in particular? Specifically with regards to brain damage that is incurred through the process of aging, would you be opposed to aging if technology could guarantee no deterioration of brain function over time? Or would this not be enough?

 

Hager wrote on February 11, 2008 5:08 AM

I would view age related diseases, such as "Alzheimer's", as a form of slowly accruing brain damage. You have to also realize that, contrary to the outdated educational standard in our country, our brain cells do split at a progressively slower rate during the aging process (as opposed to stopping altogether, as explained in the "just say no" propagandic years). Neural networks begin to deplete as they are not developed to replace themselves as quickly due to our bodies need for efficiency. This is something we have already begun to overcome. We have managed to utilize brain implants to help paraplegics walk again. When we further develope storage capacity and integrate with even more compatible bio-wet-wire technology, we'll have a better progression for augmenting intellectual capabilities. The real trick is going to replacing and upgrading bio-materials in our cerebrums at an appropriate rate, so as not to disturb our synaptic transmitter/nitric-oxide signatures. This is how we keep our conscious identity. I really shouldn't be giving too much away. But, I'm just dying from the anguish of how slow we are progressing. Too many people make negative comments without having any significant current knowledge of the material in discussion. Homework is not a bad thing! Neither is hope.

 

Sideways wrote on February 26, 2008 12:06 AM

@Dmitri --

I am living with a family member who has Alzheimer's and believe me when I say that for him, aging is brain damage. The tragedy of his condition is exactly that he is being slowly robbed of, "The wonder [that] comes from the experience of having lived the life one has lived."

I realize that Alzheimer's and aging are not the same thing. Even so, the fact remains that for a huge number of people the last years of their lives are years of brutal pain and often humiliation. I find it impossible to see how anybody who has witnessed the slow physical and mental degeneration of a loved one could not support work towards rejuvenation therapies.

 

resveratrol (Trackback) wrote on April 16, 2008 3:59 PM

Okami puts players into the role of a white wolf, the living avatar of the sun god Amaterasu, who is fighting to restore a world that’ s been spoiled at the hands of the legendary monster Orochi. Gameplay will center around a particular village of human

Join or sign in to post a comment
Submit
Advertise | Help | Contact | About | Terms | Privacy | Copyright © 2007 Betterhumans | Powered by Community Server | Partners:
World Transhumanist Association Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies Immortality Institute Methuselah Mouse Prize Foresight Institute Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence Lifeboat Foundation