in Search
0 members online
Immortality

News

Thou Shalt Not Overhype

From Genes&Aging, a justifiable note of complaint about the way the press has presented recent research: "researchers in the US have identified a gene which is reponsible both for longevity and for the retention of mental sharpness. 'Wow!', thinks I, 'my work has been done for me, we can all go home.' ... It's a nice paper, and the results are interesting and may direct research into useful areas. But: (1) It's a small study (158 people); (2) The results are only just statistically significant; (3) Other factors (other genes, environment, nutrition, exercise...) appear to be more important in influencing the phenotype than the gene itself; (4) "Cognitive function" was measured with a single test. ... Neither the general public, nor the researchers, nor science itself is done any good by hyping results such as these into news of supergenes which are going to turn us all into centenarian geniuses. It's never that simple." You have to read the popular science press with a critical eye.

View the Article Under Discussion: http://genesandaging.blogspot.com/2006/12/ageing-genes-back-in-news.html
Read More Longevity Meme Commentary: http://www.longevitymeme.org/news/
Published Thursday, December 28, 2006 8:28 PM by Longevity Meme News and Commentary

Comment Notification

Join or sign in to track comments

Comments

 

Abolitionist wrote on December 29, 2006 2:14 AM

it's a tough balance - we need sensationalism to overcome inertia and get people to realize just how much our genetic design controls who we are and the extent that we can improve by taking responsibility for our procreation.

it is exciting to find a single gene that relates to both longevity and mental functioning

Join or sign in to post a comment
Submit
Advertise | Help | Contact | About | Terms | Privacy | Copyright © 2007 Betterhumans | Powered by Community Server | Partners:
World Transhumanist Association Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies Immortality Institute Methuselah Mouse Prize Foresight Institute Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence Lifeboat Foundation